Saturday, February 16, 2008

The Quarterly Journal of Economics

I am surprised at the direction taken by economics these days. Obama is asking behavioural economists policy advice, development is only studied through randomized experiments, and happiness is becoming more important than GDP! If you look at what was published in the Quarterly Journal of Economics in the last years you might indeed be surprised.

According to its website, “The Quarterly Journal of Economics is the oldest professional journal of economics in the English language. Edited at Harvard University's Department of Economics, it covers all aspects of the field—from the journal's traditional emphasis on microtheory, to both empirical and theoretical macroeconomics. QJE is invaluable to professional and academic economists and students around the world”.

While there are still articles about inflation and exchange rates, most are really different from the public’s perception of economics. For example, they look at how Preschool Television Viewing affects Adolescent Test Scores, at how Fox News affects Voting, at how Large are the Effects from Changes in Family Environment (by studying Korean American Adoptees), at how hard it is to obtain a Driver's License in India, at how beliefs are formed, at the effect of Birth Weight on Adult Outcome, at how Friendships Form, at The Political Economy of Hatred , at how to explain sexual behaviour and at the Gender Differences in Mate Selection in a Speed Dating Experiment.

I wonder if it’s the same thing in the leading journal of the profession, the American Economic Review. Probably, with articles like "Fatal Attraction: Salience, Naïveté, and Sophistication in Experimental “Hide-and-Seek” Games"!

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Translatantic lessons from Mr. Obama

What the super exciting and always interesting election for the Presidency of the United states and the always boring and pathetic n-th election (for another short-lived legislature) in Italy have in common is the following fact: the age distance between the two contenders for the presidency on both sides of the Atlantic is at least 20 years (wow!).
John Mccain, (71), I heard on BBC today, could be the oldest president ever elected. His contender (fingers crossed) Barack Obama, being 46, if elected, would not be that far from Kennedy's record (43 when he was elected). In Italy, Mr Berlusconi is 71, while is contender, Mr. Veltroni is 52. This generational gaps are a timid signal that political campaigns may in the future become more polarized.

I read here that Obama's investment on the votes of the <=25 has been intense. This is good news since it seems to me a major break with the past. The conventional wisdom is that betting on young people's vote is a political disaster. This is a wisdom that assumes young people do not participate, do not vote, do not care... Of course this is a flawed conjecture, I would say a typical example of self-fulfilling prophecy: young people do not vote because they have never found somebody willingto represent them politically. Why would young people invest their time in politics if nobody is listening to them?Actually, that young people are not involved in politics is also dismissed by anecdotal evidence: just look at how strong has been their support to the no-global movement. The way politicians have neglected the youths in the past has produced a terrible side effect: a generation of frustrated voters animated (correctly) by anti-politics rhetoric.

Somebody may see this development as a sort of recurring cycle. The resurgent interest in politics from the young people we see today may in fact come as a response to the terrible political mistake of the Iraq war (just as the 68's movement was with the Vietnam war). If you accept this parallel (and the paradigm that history comes in circle then), somebody has to bear the responsibility to improve on it (remember Kundera?). It seems like Obama, the man of Change, is the man. He is making a coreageous bet, something that may be politically costly, but to which he must be given enormous credit. Reconciling young people with politics is a valueless legacy for every society, and I am sure the US will benefit from it (especially so if Obama gets elected, fingers crossed!!).
I see that somebody in my country (Mr. Veltroni), is trying to learn from Obama's lesson. Unfortunately, he seems to be timedely doing it, but still...

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Who cares about inflation?

Ignorant pseudo-academics who proclaimed themselves to be leftist, alter-globalists and "in touch with people's real problems" often dismiss economists for saying that it is more important to fight inflation than unemployment. In reality, no economists like price stability for the sake of it, and unemployment is the real thing that everybody wants to fight. If Central Banks around the World have decided to focus their monetary policy on controlling inflation, it is because it is the best tool to avoid the serious problems of the economy: recessions, people coming out of universities looking for jobs for 5 years before deciding to shift vocations, people not having enough money to buy basic necessities, criminality, homelessness, closing of theatres, cinemas, libraries covered with dust, trees cut down, people hating each other, war.

To correct this misinformation, the European Central Bank (ECB) has designed this "information kit" for young teenagers and teachers in all the official languages of the European Union. According to one of Geneva's leading macroeconomists who prefered to remain anonymous, this is one of the best propaganda ever. Entitled "Price stability: why is it important for you?", it consists of "of an eight-minute animated film, leaflets for pupils and a teachers' booklet. The film features two secondary school pupils, Anna and Alex, finding out about price stability. The leaflets provide an easy-to-understand overview of the topic, whereas the booklet covers it in greater detail."

I had a look at the pupil's leaflet. Unfortunately, I don't imagine it could convince people that "price stability promotes economic growth and employment by making it eaiser to compare prices and by reducing the cost of borrowing money". This is how bad economists can be when trying to influence people. Some are a bit better. When I took my undergrad class in monetary economics with this guy, I was convinced inflation had to be beaten.

All in all, controlling inflation is super important and most people don't get why. This is economists's fault.

Monday, February 4, 2008

What your policy Barack?

On the eve of Super Tuesday, while 4 people are still in the race, I am still wondering how different Hillary’s policies are from Obama’s so I went on the New York Times website and here is what’s important:

On Iraq, while Barack was the only one against from the start, both Democrats want a phased withdrawal to start soon while both Republicans are in favour of troop increase.

On healthcare, Hillary wants compulsory insurance for everyone, a.k.a. universal coverage. Obama wants a bit more flexibility while the Republicans are for more free markets.

On abortion, the Republicans are, well, crazy (against it all together). Obama is even more liberal than Hillary on this.

On Climate Change, the Democrats want compulsory cap and trade and so does McCain. Romney wants a global program (or is this an excuse?)

On immigration, the Republicans disagree. McCain, as both Democrats, supports a path to legalization that includes learning English while Romney wants none of this; he wants to build a more efficient fence. What’s crazy is that they all voted for the fence along the Mexican border.

On Iran, none of them put the war option off the table. Barack is the only one that would engage in direct diplomacy while Romney is the only one that would invade without asking Congress. They all want sanctions.

On "the economy", the Republicans want the Bush tax cuts to become permanent while the Democrats want none of that for the riches (250 000$ a year) but tax relief for the poorer to stabilize the economy.

On free trade, Hillary is now a hardcore protectionist. She wants “smart, pro-American trade because NAFTA has hurt workers”. She’s against CAFTA and wants more American agriculture exports!!! McCain and Romney are pro-free trade, in a good way. Obama is also protectionist: he wants labor & environmental standards in trade agreements and affirms that people don't want cheaper T-shirts if it costs their job. He also wants to reinvest in communities that are burdened by globalization, as most economists suggest.

All in all, this in no way helps in choosing one. Watching them talk on TV helps much more.

Friday, February 1, 2008

Obama for President!

Who says ordinary americans don't like Obama? Hulk Hogan just endorsed him!!!


But I'm still wondering which economist is for whom...Krugman seems to be for Hillary, Paul Volcker endorsed Obama, Glaeser of Harvard endorsed McCain, Mankiw seems to agree...I think most American economists are Republican cuz it's more market oriented...But I'll check that more carefully...

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

A new Kid on the block


His name is Fu-Long, the first panda born in Captivity in Europe (after 25 years). You can meet him at Vienna Zoo.

Fighting the slowdown in the US

Once again the FED has cut the interest rate by 50 basis points. This was not unexpected after the gloomy figure about GDP growth in 2007. So the FED is just doing what every macroeconomist would suggest to do when a slowdown is hitting the economy. But, the US government is preparing another plan to stimulate the economy, which contemplates the US of fiscal policy.
The so-called fiscal stimulus has not been well acclaimed by many respected economists, as PL has shown in the last post. The reason is that Fiscal Policy is not considered today the best instrument for short-term stabilization. There are two problems associated with fiscal policy as a macroeconomic tool: first, it is hard to conceive (because of the many distortions that it can provoke); second, it takes time to assess its impact.
Coming to the US package, among the main arguments the critics have advanced, I endorse the words of our Master of Thought Paul Krugman, who claims the package is ill conceived because it is targeted to the people who needed it less. In short, these are the people who probably do not suffer for a temporary lack of liquidity (not the people highly indebted, not the poorest).
When and if the policy will start to appear as ineffective, the US government will be probably forced to propose another plan, but it will take some time to realize this, which may be probably be too much, given the magnitude of the problems the US economy is facing. The risks are two. One is that, when expectations start to come at play, a slowdown may turn into a recession; if no sign of recovery appears, the FED will have to keep on sustaining the economy by a further tax cut, but here comes the second problem: monetary policy ceases to be effective when the interest rate reaches very low rate. Mr Bernanke will never try to reach the neighborhood of zero for any reason, but his room for manouvre is shrinking after today's cut. So if the fiscal package is not effective, the problems for Mr. Bernanke will become bigger. There is of course another path to follow. What the Us government can and should do, is probably listen to Mr Summers' suggestion to strengthen the financial sector. After the recent mess, this is something that needs to be done. The road to reform is a painful one, but it probably avoids the problem associated with the expectations channels: it signals the intention to fight a recession at every cost, plus providing long term beneficial effects.